Claude or Gemini for writing in English?

Anthropic's best model against Google's best, on the same English prompts, in blind duels: the gap on the leaderboard, the direct record, and the kinds of writing where Gemini comes closest.

The verdict

Claude Fable 5.2 by Anthropic (thinking adaptive high) writes better English than Gemini 4 Hydrogen by Google (thinking high) in our blind duels: rank 2 against rank 16 on the leaderboard, score 92.6 against 84.2.

The two have not met in a direct duel yet.

The two models on the leaderboard
ModelRankScoreDuels
Claude Claude Fable 5.2 💡 adaptive high292.6173
Gemini Gemini 4 Hydrogen 💡 high1684.2164

Each side is its best-ranked variant in this edition: Claude Fable 5.2 by Anthropic (thinking adaptive high) for Claude, Gemini 4 Hydrogen by Google (thinking high) for Gemini. When a better variant of either arrives, this page follows it.

Kind of writing by kind of writing

Score and rank recomputed on the duels of each category alone; the leader is in colour. Click a kind of writing for its full ranking.

Kind of writing by kind of writing
Kind of writingClaudeGeminiDirect duels
Articles, blogs and editorial93.4 #8——
Dialogue and screenplay92.8 #17——
Explanation and popularization82.8 #13——
Fiction and narrative97.7 #8——
Marketing and sales92.7 #11——
Personal communication—86.1 #18—
Professional and administrative—77.1 #21—
Social media and short formats91.4 #10——
Speech and public speaking94.8 #8——
Structured documents and reports73.2 #40——

Direct duels read wins–ties–losses for the first model. A dash means the model has not yet been judged in that category.

What each side stands for

“Claude” is the Anthropic model that ranks highest on the English leaderboard at export time, “Gemini” the Google cloud model that does. Google’s local Gemma models are a different family and have their own head-to-head with Qwen. The exact variants are named in the table above.

What the numbers measure

Blind duels only: two anonymous texts for the same English prompt, an AI judge picking the better one without seeing the names. The direct record counts the duels where these two variants met; the kind-of-writing table recomputes the ranking on one category at a time.

How to choose

On the duels judged so far, Gemini comes closest in explanation and popularization, and its weakest category is structured documents and reports. Personal letters and emails are where Claude pulls furthest ahead. Check the categories table for the kinds of writing you do most, then read the example pair below.