ChatGPT or Gemini for writing in English?

OpenAI's best model against Google's best, on the same English prompts, in blind duels: who leads on the leaderboard, how the direct duels went, and where each one is stronger.

The verdict

GPT-6.1 Sol by OpenAI (thinking high) writes better English than Gemini 4 Hydrogen by Google (thinking high) in our blind duels: rank 1 against rank 16 on the leaderboard, score 95.0 against 84.2.

Head to head, ChatGPT takes 100.0% of the points over 1 direct duels (1 win, 0 ties, 0 losses). ChatGPT leads in 2 of the 2 kinds of writing where both have been judged, Gemini in 0.

The two models on the leaderboard
ModelRankScoreDuels
ChatGPT GPT-6.1 Sol 💡 high195.02,723
Gemini Gemini 4 Hydrogen 💡 high1684.2164

Each side is its best-ranked variant in this edition: GPT-6.1 Sol by OpenAI (thinking high) for ChatGPT, Gemini 4 Hydrogen by Google (thinking high) for Gemini. When a better variant of either arrives, this page follows it.

Kind of writing by kind of writing

Score and rank recomputed on the duels of each category alone; the leader is in colour. Click a kind of writing for its full ranking.

Kind of writing by kind of writing
Kind of writingChatGPTGeminiDirect duels
Articles, blogs and editorial98.4 #1——
Dialogue and screenplay98.3 #1——
Explanation and popularization74.0 #22——
Fiction and narrative96.6 #10——
Marketing and sales94.7 #7——
Personal communication97.3 #286.1 #181–0–0
Professional and administrative85.1 #577.1 #21—
Social media and short formats96.9 #1——
Speech and public speaking98.5 #1——
Structured documents and reports96.5 #1——

Direct duels read wins–ties–losses for the first model. A dash means the model has not yet been judged in that category.

What each side stands for

“ChatGPT” is the OpenAI model that ranks highest on the English leaderboard at export time, “Gemini” the Google cloud model that does. Both companies ship fast and full-size models under the same brand; the table above names the exact variants that stand for each side today, and the full leaderboard shows the others.

What the numbers measure

Blind duels: two anonymous texts for the same English prompt, an AI judge picking the better one without seeing the names. The direct record counts only the duels where these two variants met. The kind-of-writing table recomputes the ranking on one category at a time.

How to choose

These two are often closer on documents and explanations than on letters, marketing and fiction, where voice matters more. Check the categories you write most, then read the example pair at the bottom of the page: a real duel with its published verdict.

Writing example

Write a warm thank-you note (50–150 words) to your neighbor, Mrs. Patel, who watered your tomato plants and fed your cat, Biscuit, during the two weeks you were away visiting family. Mention that you brought her back a small jar of orange-blossom honey as a gesture of thanks, that the cat clearly missed her already, and that you'd be happy to return the favor whenever she next travels. Keep the tone friendly and sincere, as if slipping the note under her door.

Published verdict: ChatGPT (judged by Claude Opus 5.5).

ChatGPT · GPT-6.1 Sol 💡 high

Dear Mrs. Patel,

Thank you so much for watering my tomato plants and feeding Biscuit while I was away visiting family these past two weeks. It was such a comfort knowing they were in your care, and I came home to happy plants and a very contented cat.

Biscuit clearly misses you already—he keeps looking toward the door as though he’s expecting another visit! I brought you back a small jar of orange-blossom honey as a little thank-you. I hope you enjoy it.

Whenever you next travel, I’d be happy to return the favor. Thank you again for being such a thoughtful neighbor.

Warmly,
Your grateful neighbor

Gemini · Gemini 4 Hydrogen 💡 high

Dear Mrs. Patel,

Thank you so much for watering my tomato plants and feeding Biscuit during the two weeks I was away visiting family. The plants are thriving, and Biscuit has been sitting by the front door since I got back, clearly missing you already!

I brought you back a small jar of orange-blossom honey as a gesture of thanks, which I’ve left right outside your door.

It gave me such peace of mind knowing everything was in your kind hands. Please let me know whenever you next travel—I would be happy to return the favor!

Warmly,
Your neighbor